New York hotels near Madison Square Park

Pros: Location.

Cons: Customer service was not at a 5 star level. The room was pretty basic, very clean but nothing spectacular about the room. The restroom was nice though.

Pros: All; Great location, big and clean room, nice hospitality, wifi

Pros: Location was close to everything. Comfortable room to come back to after exploring.

Cons: NA

Pros: Room was nice and clean. Comfy bed and pillows.

Cons: For 5 stars the room was extremely small and very basic. No bath. No view. If driving to hotel keep in mind its in the middle of times square. Traffic is crazy. Hotel offers valet and they take car to parking garage which you could find one yourself.

Pros: Large bath sheets When I called guest services they answered using my name Staff very friendly and so helpful

Cons: Shower could do with more pressure

Pros: The staff was most accommodating to make sure of our comfort and the availability of assistance, right from the start, our bellman made sure our concerns or inquiries got answered. Best "Times Square" hotel for me!

Cons: Some of the amenities of a 5 star include asking for anything and everything one requires, through the desk. I could walk to an ice machine faster than the line was answered-sometimes.

Pros: Continental breakfast was quite okay but could do with changes day-to-day. Consistent in room decor and stylien

Cons: Confusing lobby area. This could be fixed by relocating reception to the left side of the entry area rather than way up the end of the hall. It is too dimly lit too in my opinion. Our Junior Suite (1501) was quite dark with small windows. The complimentary tablet is a gimmick and is not likely to be useful to anyone with a smartphone or their own tablet/laptop. No hand towel rack—where do you put them? Disconcertingly loose bathroom/shower fittings. No coffee. Stain on couch.

Pros: Location

Cons: Room

Pros: The friendly atmosphere

Cons: The run down carpet in hall ways

Pros: I liked the concierge service especially Eric . He was so helpful and friendly . Excellent staff . I am so impressed.

Cons: When we checked in ... there were a few spots of housekeeping that wasn’t met . We pointed it out and it was immediately taken care of .

Pros: I liked the bathroom and the workout facility.

Cons: Our floor 10 was in very poor condition. The carpet was ripped, dirty and had stretched areas that you trip over. The main hallways smelled of overwhelming cheap perfume that gave me a bit of a headache. I mentioned the smell to the front desk and they said they receive compliments on the smell so maybe it’s just me, but smelled like the perfume section of a department store. There’s no coffee or tea available in the room, just an expensive mini bar. We had a drink in the lounge and the drinks were an atrocious price, like they were an exclusive club (but not). It kinda felt like this hotel was a nice hotel 20 years ago but now is in disrepair. However, the bed was comfortable enough and the room was quiet so I did sleep well. You’re not suppose to hang out in your hotel in New York anyway right?

Pros: The rooms are spacious and beautiful with comfortable beds and pillows!! The best part of our room was the peace and quiet on Times Square. The subway is steps away. Need tickets, need anything just ask one of the 2 concierge or 3 check in angels. We had the best 3 days in NYC ever and had home to come back to each night!!! You want it all, stay at the Knick!!!

Cons: Busy lifts at night.

Pros: Shower Bed Large tv

Cons: One of the dim able bedside lamps didn't dim

Pros: Great location. Great decor. The books everywhere gave it a cool and relaxing atmosphere. Loved housekeeping twice a day. Quiet. I really liked that they have no tub. Showers are so much cleaner and relaxing.

Cons: No bar. No restaurant....yet. We should of been told of that when we booked.

Pros: The location was excellent, close to Subway, great restaurants and shopping.

Cons: Noise in room on 11th floor (119) coming from elevator (we think) was like someone using an industrial stapler in the early morning hours. Unfortunately I'm a light sleeper.

Pros: The room was awesome, great bed and decor. Short stay so didn’t get to experience everything on offer but enjoyed what we had time to

Cons: The gym was teeny tiny, max 2 people at a time. I didn’t like the fact that we had to pay for absolutely everything, water, coffee capsules etc plus a 10% re fill fee...on top of all the other extra fees, you would think for the price you pay they could offer you one coffee capsule and water each

Pros: Location

Cons: The room was very small!!!

Pros: Loved the location and atmosphere

Cons: Room was way smaller than expected. we traveled almost 3 hours and arrived an hour before check in at 4, but our room wasn’t ready til almost 5

Pros: Trendy. Location. Friendly staff. Comfortable bed.

Cons: My heater wasn’t working

Pros: Room was comfortable, very efficient for the space and quiet. NYC can be loud due to traffic and people, but I was not disturbed! They also welcomed me with a personal, hand-written note in the room.

Pros: Location

Cons: They charge at least 5 USD per package if you get anything delivered. Check-in process is a nightmare. No closet in the rooms. Not good for business trips.

Pros: Location, cool atmosphere.

Cons: Tiny room, loud a/c.

Pros: Clean

Cons: Nothing

Pros: The hotel is a new concept which is clean and organized with recent technologies embedded all over. The staff are nice (although some of them have to smile more). But in general they were really helpful. I would like to thank Steven (the doorman) for his help in which he was generous enough to walk me to buy a SIM card. In addition, the receptionist Ivette was very helpful and supportive all the time. The breakfast was good and the location is perfect.

Cons: The main issue was the loud noise especially on a weekend night. I could not sleep. Even the sounds from the street were really loud although my room was on the fifth floor. The AC sound is loud as well!

Pros: location, modern room and great vibe.

Cons: Very small room.

Pros: Super comfortable beds, great location cool bar and super friendly staff

Cons: I know its NYC but rooms are small

Cons: Tokyo Style; Super Small Rooms!

Pros: It has a vibrant atmosphere and the service is delivered nicely. The rooms have everything you need including ironing and dryer. Connected to the hotel there are a café and a restaurant with good products.

Cons: The triple room had the sink in the room instead of in the toilet, nothing too tragic.

Pros: nice, young, up to date, very cool

Cons: not at all

Pros: Loved the location, friendly staff, beautiful room and croissant breakfast!

Pros: We made reservation on line than showed up and the hotel was sold out

Cons: Read above

Pros: Location and the restaurant.

Cons: The staff was rude. The atmosphere is gloomy. The electricity is ancient. The tub was clogged. Was woken up with a knock at 8 am on the day I was checking out. Valet took 35 minutes to bring my car.

Pros: The rooms were cute. Not to small.

Cons: Stayed here for New Year's Eve. Wanted a bucket of ice for the room so my wife and I could keep a bottle of champagne cold. They actually charged us $5 for the bucket of ice. Not even Motel 6 charges for ice. Room was also very hot and a lot of noise from the street and hallway. Bed hard and uncomfortable.

Cons: No breakfast room. Tiny rooms for price.

Pros: It is a quiet part of New York to be in right next to Gramercy Park so no noisy avenues and car horns going off all night! Easy to get around from that Location with good weekend markets in many of the parks or squares. A good dressing room! Plenty of storage except the safe was too high for me to reach!

Cons: Bedroom was very dark and bathroom dated and small. Shower did not work properly but was adequate. I do wish American hotels would provide Tea and Coffee in the rooms like the rest of the hotels in the World. I had to order room service for a cup of morning tea. The cup was tiny needing to be refilled after about 3 sips. The croissant was huge! Would rather it was the other way around. Service is included in the bar which is a shame as it was not very good. Not up to the usual high level of bar staff.

Pros: very cool but small bedroom.

Cons: too small

Pros: The hotel was centrally located, yet on a quit street in the city. The staff were stupendous and the rooms lovely. I had a very pleasant stay and can't wait to return.

Cons: DARK interior room facing a dirty wall for $1,000 per night. Whats not to love? Front desk receptionist as welcoming and friendly as a broom.

Pros: Got upgraded to a double queen room and the size of the room is amazing by NY standards! You get one free item (non-alcoholic) per day from the mini bar which they include as part of the mandatory resort fee.

Cons: Bathroom is a bit small and water takes a long time to heat up - it also doesn’t get hot enough.

Pros: Perfectly located hotel, close to subway and the avenues. The lobby area is very pleasant for relaxing, we loved the cheese and wine tasting every afternoon.

Cons: We had some minor issues in the room, but the staff managed the problems very quickly and in a satisfactory way.

Pros: I like the comfort of the bed, the cleanliness of the room as well as the service from the people working in the hotel. It is great also to have a cool restaurant and bar right in the hotel as well.

Cons: The room was fairly small and quite dark to be honest - Despite being on the 7th floor I could have expected more light. The room can be noisy as I would hear very easily people talking in the corridor or when a door get slammed.

Pros: Great location. Staff was excellent. Clean, convenient and surprisingly spacious for a NYC hotel room.

Pros: Rooms are spacious which is a luxury in Manhattan. Location is great, nothing to fault.

Pros: Complementary wine and cheese was a bonus! The location was better than I expected, and the room was very spacious and clean!

Cons: The windows could have been a bit thicker considering the area, but the street noise did not bother me. The doors are not sound proofed, and our room was directly facing the elevator, we definitely heard guests coming in and out of the elevator.

Cons: Did not like the decor. Breakfast was good bed comfortable

Pros: The whole staff and hotel accommodations Were great. I am definitely staying here again. Convenient, clean and great front desk and behind the scenes staff.

Cons: I will preface this review by saying we stayed at the Soho location which was absolutely fantastic. Here at NoMad it was totally different. The front desk woman upon arrival suggested we upgrade our room because of the beautiful view, larger room, and great location- the room was no bigger than my home closet and there was absolutely NO view (unless staring at another building is a view) AND it was incredibly noisy- constant sirens, horns, etc. It was not clean upon arrival- there was black splotches on the walls, orange splotches on the bathroom walls, broken towel hooks on the back of the bathroom door, broken door hinge in the bathroom door, AND the knob on the inside of the shower door fell off and I had to figure out how to screw it back on so I could get out of the shower. No one ever answered the phone at the front desk OR concierge OR valet from 9:30am to 1:30pm the day of our checkout despite calling 20 times- my husband had to go down to the front desk himself in order to get a bellhop to carry our luggage down and get Our car. None of this would be a big deal if I was staying at the Holiday Inn because you typically get what you pay for- for a AAA 4Diamond hotel I expected a bit more especially considering the cost per night. Unfortunately to say we were disappointed is a understatement. We throughly enjoyed our stay at SoHo but after our stay at the NoMad location we likely won’t return.

Pros: Great beds and large room Great bar in the hotel Nice free happy hour

Cons: Not very helpful staff Waited twice over an hour for come cups to be delivered to the room so we could drink water

Pros: The location

Pros: Location was wonderful and the staff did an excellent job

Cons: Hotel was a bit on the pricier side for what it was.