Best New York inns
Overall 9.0 Excellent
Based on 206 reviews
All reviews
- All reviews
Details
Reviews
Overall 9.0 Excellent
Based on 206 reviews
Vibe
9.6
Location
9.0
Service
8.4
Room
8.3
Amenities
8.0
With a stay at The Inn at Irving Place in New York (Midtown), you'll be within a 5-minute walk of 5th Avenue and Union Square Park. Featured amenities include a business center, limo/town car service, and express check-in.
Overall 8.8 Excellent
Based on 83 reviews
All reviews
- All reviews
Details
Reviews
Overall 8.8 Excellent
Based on 83 reviews
Vibe
9.6
Location
9.5
Service
9.1
Comfort
7.9
Room
7.0
WiFi
5.0
With a stay at The Inn at Irving Place in New York (Midtown), you'll be within a 5-minute walk of 5th Avenue and Union Square Park. Featured amenities include a business center, limo/town car service, and express check-in.
A stay at Incentra Village Hotel places you in the heart of New York, within a 10-minute walk of Chelsea Market and Whitney Museum of American Art. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby and luggage storage.
Overall 8.4 Excellent
Based on 199 reviews
All reviews
- All reviews
- Couples
Excellent
9.6
Pros: Excellent, very friendly staff, and in a great location.
Excellent
10.0
Pros: Plenty of places to nosh and location to social activities is excellent. We are saving our pennies for another stay in the near future!
Good
7.9
Pros: The location was perfect for I had planned.
Excellent
9.6
Pros: The bathroom was lovely, the Garden Suite had a charming private back garden and the kitchenette was clean and well supplied. The West Village location is perfect!
Good
7.9
Pros: loved the kitchen facilities, location, space
Excellent
10.0
Pros: We liked the homey feel and the staff was so nice and helpful
Excellent
8.8
Pros: Quiet accommodations with a beautiful room. So close to the Stonewall bar/national historic site , lovely side streets with inviting cafes.
Excellent
10.0
Pros: Everything about Incentra was amazing. The rooms are decorated beautifully. The Staff was excellent, so very friendly and helpful. We can’t wait to go back.
Mediocre
2.5
Excellent
8.3
Pros: Great location. Nice toiletries provided. Kitchenette perfect for short stay, making breakfast, etc. Kettle, microwave and toaster provided. Bathroom very nice. Plenty of hot water.
Excellent
9.6
Pros: Location is great; very close by to a subway station taking you straight to JFK or LaGuardia airport. Bedroom was lovely with a kitchnette; plates, glasses, cutlery, coffee machine with coffee and filters all provided; fridge. Beautiful bedroom and setting. Area is very lovely. Great at keeping in touch with you.
Details
Reviews
Overall 8.4 Excellent
Based on 199 reviews
Location
9.8
Service
8.8
Room
6.4
Cleanliness
5.0
Comfort
3.8
Amenities
2.7
Location
9.8
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Excellent, very friendly staff, and in a great location.
Cons:
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Plenty of places to nosh and location to social activities is excellent. We are saving our pennies for another stay in the near future!
Cons:
7.9 Good
Pros: The location was perfect for I had planned.
Cons: An old establishment, that could do with an upgrade, but the staff were the best.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The bathroom was lovely, the Garden Suite had a charming private back garden and the kitchenette was clean and well supplied. The West Village location is perfect!
Cons: The staircase down to our room was very narrow.
7.9 Good
Pros: loved the kitchen facilities, location, space
Cons: needed a small sharp knife and soap in the bathroom.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: We liked the homey feel and the staff was so nice and helpful
Cons: It was exactly what we needed, better than Airbnb
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Quiet accommodations with a beautiful room. So close to the Stonewall bar/national historic site , lovely side streets with inviting cafes.
Cons: A little cramped - but an older house, so I guess it's to be expected. Very charming.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everything about Incentra was amazing. The rooms are decorated beautifully. The Staff was excellent, so very friendly and helpful. We can’t wait to go back.
Cons: I couldn’t fault it.
2.5 Mediocre
Pros:
Cons: The room the service Not clean No cancellation policy
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Great location. Nice toiletries provided. Kitchenette perfect for short stay, making breakfast, etc. Kettle, microwave and toaster provided. Bathroom very nice. Plenty of hot water.
Cons: A/C very loud. Turning on and off all night disrupted our sleep. Beds very squeaky, so every movement made a noise. Told staff about broken lamp on first day. Still wasn’t fixed eleven days later.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Location is great; very close by to a subway station taking you straight to JFK or LaGuardia airport. Bedroom was lovely with a kitchnette; plates, glasses, cutlery, coffee machine with coffee and filters all provided; fridge. Beautiful bedroom and setting. Area is very lovely. Great at keeping in touch with you.
Cons:
A stay at Incentra Village Hotel places you in the heart of New York, within a 10-minute walk of Chelsea Market and Whitney Museum of American Art. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby and luggage storage.
The Seafarers International House is an ideal choice for travelers who want to take in the sights and sounds of New York. This property features Wi-Fi in designated areas. Boasting a convenient location, the hotel is just 2km from Grand Central Terminal and 23km from Newark Liberty International Airport. The closest major public transportation, Union Square Metro Station, is only 300m away. Many local tourist attractions including the Chinatown and Fifth Avenue can easily be reached with a short drive. In their spare time, guests can explore the hotel's surroundings.
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 2,469 reviews
All reviews
- All reviews
- Solo
- Couples
- Families
Excellent
8.3
Pros: Washstand, room with table and chair. Ability to leave bags after checkout and get them back any time. Location near Union Square, Whole Foods and Trader Joe's.
Okay
4.6
Pros: Good location close to subway, not too noisy also.
Excellent
9.6
Pros: The peace and comfort of my room. It was spacious, clean and good facilities within.
Excellent
9.2
Pros: Value for money, very clean. This was my second stay in Seafarers, i will definitely come back again.
Excellent
8.8
Pros: It's a simple accommodation, but it's totally enough considering good location (almost on the Union Square) and a private bathroom. Good WiFi, spacious room.
Good
7.0
Pros: Easy access to subway. The room was a quiet place, clean, although it could have a little fridge, was enough for me! On Wednesday there was an amazing farmer market fair in Union Square, with delicious and interesting goodies to eat and see.
Good
7.0
Pros: - The location is central - The staff is kind and helpful - Hotel was clean and calm considering how affordable it was, NYC standard affordable :)
Mediocre
3.0
Pros: I didn't know 'shared bathroom' meant 8 rooms to one WC.
Mediocre
3.0
Pros: Coffee
Good
7.1
Pros: Let’s face it, New York City is an expensive place to stay, and finding a place that is clean and well situated for an affordable price is difficult. But Seafarers fits the bill. We had a twin bedded, air conditioned, private bath corner room on the 4th floor. It was not unlike being back in our university residence, which was fine with us. The beds were comfortable, but not plushy. Linens were clean and crisp, but not 1000 thread count. The black-out curtains worked as did the ac. The decent reading lamp beside the bed was good. The bathroom was serviceable, although could probably use some tile refurbishment in the near future (see comment about the university residence) and water in the shower was hot. The location of Seafarers, just off Union Square and within walking distance of both restaurants and tourist sites is fantastic but was quite quiet for NYC. All in all, we had a good stay and will definitely stay here again, assuming we can get a reservation, as this property is much in demand.
Okay
5.0
Pros: Close enough to subway.
Details
Reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 2,469 reviews
Location
9.7
Value
9.0
Food
8.5
Service
7.1
WiFi
7.1
Room
5.9
Breakfast
2.5
Location
9.9
Value
9.1
Service
7.9
Room
6.4
WiFi
6.0
Amenities
5.9
Breakfast
2.6
Location
9.7
Value
9.1
Service
7.3
Room
4.8
Breakfast
2.0
Location
9.8
Value
9.1
Service
6.7
Cleanliness
6.4
Amenities
6.0
Room
5.2
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Washstand, room with table and chair. Ability to leave bags after checkout and get them back any time. Location near Union Square, Whole Foods and Trader Joe's.
Cons: Even though I lived on 7th floor I could hear the noises from the street. The ventilation is quite poor and you can get fresh air only opening the window increasing the noises.
4.6 Okay
Pros: Good location close to subway, not too noisy also.
Cons: BED BUGS!!!! No reaction on complains, even didn’t change bedding with bugs spots. Nasty place , be careful!
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The peace and comfort of my room. It was spacious, clean and good facilities within.
Cons: Sharing a shower room with strangers. Not everyone obeyed the care instructions.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Value for money, very clean. This was my second stay in Seafarers, i will definitely come back again.
Cons:
8.8 Excellent
Pros: It's a simple accommodation, but it's totally enough considering good location (almost on the Union Square) and a private bathroom. Good WiFi, spacious room.
Cons: Primitive shower with no soap (!!! Seriously?!), broken window, etc.
7.0 Good
Pros: Easy access to subway. The room was a quiet place, clean, although it could have a little fridge, was enough for me! On Wednesday there was an amazing farmer market fair in Union Square, with delicious and interesting goodies to eat and see.
Cons: It could have a little fridge in the room. The checkout’s time could be more flexible.
7.0 Good
Pros: - The location is central - The staff is kind and helpful - Hotel was clean and calm considering how affordable it was, NYC standard affordable :)
Cons: - The shared bathroom - The late check-in, we had to comeback 2 hours later since room wasn't ready
3.0 Mediocre
Pros: I didn't know 'shared bathroom' meant 8 rooms to one WC.
Cons: shower room had only a towel rack - no place to set anything down.
3.0 Mediocre
Pros: Coffee
Cons: No face rags
7.1 Good
Pros: Let’s face it, New York City is an expensive place to stay, and finding a place that is clean and well situated for an affordable price is difficult. But Seafarers fits the bill. We had a twin bedded, air conditioned, private bath corner room on the 4th floor. It was not unlike being back in our university residence, which was fine with us. The beds were comfortable, but not plushy. Linens were clean and crisp, but not 1000 thread count. The black-out curtains worked as did the ac. The decent reading lamp beside the bed was good. The bathroom was serviceable, although could probably use some tile refurbishment in the near future (see comment about the university residence) and water in the shower was hot. The location of Seafarers, just off Union Square and within walking distance of both restaurants and tourist sites is fantastic but was quite quiet for NYC. All in all, we had a good stay and will definitely stay here again, assuming we can get a reservation, as this property is much in demand.
Cons: Nothing, it was as we expected and perfect for our needs
5.0 Okay
Pros: Close enough to subway.
Cons: Very poor roll away bed.
The Seafarers International House is an ideal choice for travelers who want to take in the sights and sounds of New York. This property features Wi-Fi in designated areas. Boasting a convenient location, the hotel is just 2km from Grand Central Terminal and 23km from Newark Liberty International Airport. The closest major public transportation, Union Square Metro Station, is only 300m away. Many local tourist attractions including the Chinatown and Fifth Avenue can easily be reached with a short drive. In their spare time, guests can explore the hotel's surroundings.
Chelsea Pines Inn is centrally located in New York, a 4-minute walk from Chelsea Market and 7 minutes by foot from The High Line Park. Featured amenities include limo/town car service, a 24-hour front desk, and luggage storage.
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 1,243 reviews
All reviews
- All reviews
- Couples
- Families
- Solo
- Business
Okay
4.6
Pros: The location was great!!!
Good
6.3
Pros: Location was great. Not too busy an area but good for transportation to sites. More of a neighborhood area.
Excellent
8.0
Pros: I always have a great stay when I am here. My stays are always consistent. Staff is always friendly.
Okay
5.0
Pros: Run down room with a gym locker smell. Visible water damage on the walls. It needs a lot of upgrading. Very disappointed.
Good
7.5
Pros: Loved the location and security. They also brought our bags up for us!
Good
7.5
Pros: The location is perfect. A lot to see and experience is around a corner or within a walkable distance
Excellent
8.3
Pros: Staff was great. Breakfast presented an expedient option 7-10. Coffee, various breads, orange juice, cold cuts, yogurt, cold cereal, and milk were all present, but not much fruit.
Excellent
10.0
Pros: Location location location ideal for a city break 100 yards to subway. Chelsea is a fab area and hotel is central.
Excellent
10.0
Pros: No elevators and the super friendly staff made it feel so cozy. Not to mention the great garden patio and uncanny amount of quietness you get at night. Pretty amazing and 100% where I'll be staying every time I visit NYC
Okay
4.6
Pros: Location is amazing, half a block to 14th st station and a block from Chelsea market
Excellent
10.0
Pros: Quiet
Excellent
8.0
Pros: Super location in the Meatpacking District close to lots of great restaurants, as well as close proximity to several subway lines, which make it easy to get around the city; very quiet room, so it was easy to sleep and a very nice shower
Details
Reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 1,243 reviews
Location
9.8
Value
8.4
Service
8.3
Breakfast
7.5
Room
6.3
WiFi
4.5
Amenities
3.1
Location
9.8
Service
8.5
Breakfast
7.2
Food
6.8
Cleanliness
5.4
Room
4.6
Amenities
2.8
Location
9.9
Service
8.4
Breakfast
7.1
Room
5.5
Amenities
2.6
Location
9.9
Breakfast
6.8
Room
6.2
Comfort
5.2
Amenities
3.0
Location
9.9
Service
8.6
Breakfast
7.9
Room
6.3
Amenities
3.6
4.6 Okay
Pros: The location was great!!!
Cons: The air condition was very noisy so cant use during the night. There was a slot in the door so we heard everything !! outside The carpet was stinky . Room not so clean
6.3 Good
Pros: Location was great. Not too busy an area but good for transportation to sites. More of a neighborhood area.
Cons: Some staff were friendly some were borderline rude. Certainly didn’t feel welcomed. Food ran out quickly at breakfast. Had a bath May the first 2 nights but it disappeared the 3rd. Also no blow dryer
8.0 Excellent
Pros: I always have a great stay when I am here. My stays are always consistent. Staff is always friendly.
Cons: Lock on the door was a bit funny, needed to reinsert card to lock it properly. Construction outside the hotel in the middle of the night- not the hotels fault but still made sleeping a bit difficult.
5.0 Okay
Pros: Run down room with a gym locker smell. Visible water damage on the walls. It needs a lot of upgrading. Very disappointed.
Cons:
7.5 Good
Pros: Loved the location and security. They also brought our bags up for us!
Cons: Saw a big cockroach in our room.
7.5 Good
Pros: The location is perfect. A lot to see and experience is around a corner or within a walkable distance
Cons: The breakfast was mediocre. After leaving the place on the third day, I found (most probably) bed bug bites on my arms.
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Staff was great. Breakfast presented an expedient option 7-10. Coffee, various breads, orange juice, cold cuts, yogurt, cold cereal, and milk were all present, but not much fruit.
Cons: Room shape was odd. Could barely move around end of bed.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Location location location ideal for a city break 100 yards to subway. Chelsea is a fab area and hotel is central.
Cons: Street noice can be a problem a lot of early traffic each morning
10.0 Excellent
Pros: No elevators and the super friendly staff made it feel so cozy. Not to mention the great garden patio and uncanny amount of quietness you get at night. Pretty amazing and 100% where I'll be staying every time I visit NYC
Cons:
4.6 Okay
Pros: Location is amazing, half a block to 14th st station and a block from Chelsea market
Cons: I’ve stayed here before and thought it a perfect location even though it has quirky decor. However when we checked in after 11pm, the room looked nothing like the pictures. The mismatched furniture was worn and there were several spots of spackle unpainted in each room. Being so late, there wasn’t much else we could ask for and despite being a returned guest, I would never recommend this place to anyone. Bathroom shower also was dirty. Pictures attached.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Quiet
Cons: Nothing all was great. Food nearby was excellent.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Super location in the Meatpacking District close to lots of great restaurants, as well as close proximity to several subway lines, which make it easy to get around the city; very quiet room, so it was easy to sleep and a very nice shower
Cons: Servicing of the room was a bit inconsistent, but as I was only there for three days and am a super tidy person, this wasn't much of an issue
Chelsea Pines Inn is centrally located in New York, a 4-minute walk from Chelsea Market and 7 minutes by foot from The High Line Park. Featured amenities include limo/town car service, a 24-hour front desk, and luggage storage.
With a stay at 255West Guesthouse in New York (Harlem), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Apollo Theater and Columbia University. Featured amenities include luggage storage and coffee/tea in a common area.
Overall 7.8 Good
Based on 28 reviews
All reviews
- All reviews
Details
Reviews
Overall 7.8 Good
Based on 28 reviews
Location
10.0
Service
9.0
Amenities
7.0
Room
6.1
Cleanliness
2.5
With a stay at 255West Guesthouse in New York (Harlem), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Apollo Theater and Columbia University. Featured amenities include luggage storage and coffee/tea in a common area.
With a stay at MichaelNY in New York (Washington Heights), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of New York Presbyterian Hospital and Yankee Stadium.
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on reviews
Details
Reviews
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on reviews
With a stay at MichaelNY in New York (Washington Heights), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of New York Presbyterian Hospital and Yankee Stadium.
Where to stay in New York?
Our Heatmaps tool will help you find the perfect place to stay in New York by showing you how close inns are to major activities
