|"Lovely ambiance and great location."||(in 337 reviews)|
|"The cozy clean rooms."||(in 199 reviews)|
|"The bed was extremely comfortable."||(in 98 reviews)|
|"The hotel was under construction."||(in 33 reviews)|
|"no lobby /renovation!"||(in 38 reviews)|
|"The small window looked on to a brick wall."||(in 4 reviews)|
Location was great for my business in the city. Staff was nice.
The lobby was under construction, walls were thin in my room so it was noisy at night. No coffee available until 7am and I had to leave in mornings by 6:30am. Rooms were very small.
The staff were accommodating when I requested a late checkout due to an interview in the city - it was great to have a place to come back to and change before another long travel day. This is the second time I've stayed at the hotel and each time the stay has been nice, staff friendly, and rooms comfortable and clean.
Enjoyed my stay. The rooms are petit but have all you need. Bathroom a decent size with a good shower. Nice pastries in reception for breakfast + kettle to make tea / coffee. Easy walk to many midtown locations. Street noise average for NY. Staff were very friendly. Overall a very nice surprise considering I had never heard of the hotel before
WiFi often needed to be logged back in when you returned to your room but worked well when connected
Weekend Business Trip
This hotel is very cute and boutique. It's unique character is charming and inviting. I was only there for the weekend for a short business trip and the hotel was a 5 minute walk from where I needed to be, so the convenience to a lot of locations within walking/subway distance is a major plus. Even though NYC traffic is loud the hotels windows blocked out a majority of the noise, which was nice for a small city girl to be able to fall asleep easily! Overall a lovely experience at this hotel!
The only thing that was a huge issue for me, which is not the hotels fault, was all the party people coming in at all hours of the night and being unbelievably loud at 3am. Woke up several different times during both nights which wasn't fun. Heavier doors or maybe asking guests if they are in for business then putting them away from the elevators? Again, not the hotel's issue, just wasn't a restful night of sleep.
Descent hotel but location and other patrons a bit odd
I booked this last minute to get a quad room for a family. They ran out of rooms with two beds so after some back and forth gave us a suite with one bed and a couch. The weird thing about this hotel is that it is located next to the museum of sex. My 7 year old kept asking if we could visit (not good) and there were a lot of younger/partying people on our floor that yelled into the night. Overall this hotel is fine, but beware of the slightly odd location.
Museum next door and younger crowd- not great for families
Great for a quick comfortable stay
Great place to stay! Convenient location in a non touristy part of the city. Being a former long-time resident of Grammercy, this is nice and close to my home neighborhood. Small but efficient and comfortable rooms, nice toiletries, good beds and linens, quiet.
Don't Expect Much
Nice staff, powerful shower, nice bathroom fixtures, good liens and firm bed.
Very small and noisy. Radiant headed floors in bathroom would not heat. Two requests of front desk staff to have repaired not fulfilled. No room make up after 2nd night. No coffee service in the room. A pot of coffee shows up at 7am in the lobby with small pastries. No napkins, they have a box of facial tissues. New Yorker visitors much be used to poor value.
The room was comfortable but no view. The location was convenient.
The counter staff were rather aloof and totally inflexible with regards to the check in check out times.
It was very clean. The room was stylish and comfy. The location is amazing.
They can't help it- they are in the process of remodeling. No lobby, no area for breakfast, no ice machine. These things will probably all be back when the hotel is finished being remodeled. Great value.
Jeremy and the staff that we dealt with were super helpful and accommodating!
The elevator isn't the quickest...
A great homebase
The room is beautiful. High ceilings, great fixtures, great bad… And all very well laid out. It was in a fantastic location, just north of the flat iron district.
The only downside of my stay there, was the fact that it was under renovation in the lobby. I didn't bother me… Staff was excellent, the room beautiful.
Nice finished in room.
Room was smaller than expected. 1 slow elevator. Shower didn't operate correctly.
With a stay at The Evelyn Hotel, you'll be centrally located in New York, steps from 5th Avenue and 4 minutes by foot from Madison Square Garden. Featured amenities include a business center, limo/town car service, and express check-in.
Based on 3,500 reviews
Policies vary by room type and provider.