Simpson Bay car rentals

Simpson Bay car rentals

Search hundreds of hire car sites at once for hire car deals in Simpson Bay

Simpson Bay, St. Maarten
29 Sep — 6 Oct
Same drop-off
Simpson Bay, St. Maarten
Wed 29/9
Noon
Wed 6/10
Noon
Driver's age:

Search hundreds of hire car sites at once for hire car deals in Simpson Bay

Simpson Bay car rental information

Pick-up locationSimpson Bay
Rental locations59
Airport locations37

Simpson Bay car hire reviews and directory

Rated no. 1
Ace
Best rated
7.1 Good (62 reviews)
1 location in Simpson Bay
Ace
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 6.8
  • 6.8
  • 6.9
  • 7.5
  • 7.2
Recent reviews
10.0 Excellent9 Sep 2021
Everything with Ace was excellent!
10.0 Excellent30 Aug 2021
Everything was excellent except the car was not good condition
7.9 Good4 Aug 2021
Convient location to airport
2.0 Mediocre22 Jun 2021
Staff was friendly and helpfull and the drop off was quick and good.The car was far from good, the remote did not work, I had to close all 4 doors and the trunk everytime manually, the car was full of scratches. No Tank cover.
8.0 Excellent17 May 2021
Car was a bit of a wreck. Old.
10.0 Excellent27 Apr 2021
staff friendly, pick up easycar a bit raggedy
10.0 Excellent13 Feb 2021
Derrick was very friendly and helpful.nothing, all went well.
8.0 Excellent31 Jan 2021
Pickup/dropoff and staff all very good.Car was old with a poor alignment and a problematic trunk.
2.0 Mediocre23 Jan 2021
Not at allAll
4.4 Okay1 Feb 2020
Staff were greatCars are extremely horrible and never what you’re selecting online
Show more reviews
Rated no. 2
NextCar
10 Excellent (1 review)
1 location in Simpson Bay
NextCar
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
Recent reviews
10.0 Excellent13 Jun 2021
Pickup and drop off were very easy. They had frequent shuttles to and from the airport.
Rated no. 3
Routes Car & Truck Rentals
10 Excellent (1 review)
1 location in Simpson Bay
Routes Car & Truck Rentals
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
Recent reviews
Rated no. 4
Hertz
8.3 Excellent (8 reviews)
6 locations in Simpson Bay
Hertz
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 7.7
  • 8.2
  • 8.4
  • 9
  • 8.7
Recent reviews
7.9 Good8 Aug 2021
My car was old and it smelled funny. Paint on car was scratched and not shiny brand new. A little disappointed. Service was great though. Fast and efficient service for both pick up and drop off. 3.5 stars out of 5.
8.0 Excellent12 Jun 2021
Flexibility on the return was excellent. Normally the office opens at 8:00 a.m., but we had an 8:30 flight, so we had to return the car by ~6:30. They don’t have a drop-box (which would be helpful!), but they arranged for the security guard to drive us to the air terminal. This eased a lot of stress about how we would return the car on-time, as we were staying across the island and would have had difficulty had we had to return the car the previous day.Condition of the car was fair - many scratches and scuffs. However, I think that’s simply one of the realities of having a car on an island with roads that are narrow and in poor condition overall.
10.0 Excellent23 Feb 2017
I was pleased particularly with the fact that I was provided a GPS at no extra charge. Without a GPS, I would not have been able to navigate throughout the island.Everything was perfect.
8.0 Excellent4 Dec 2016
Good Value... Very Friendly StaffTransaction was quick start to finish. Short line moved quickly. Hertz staff was very courteous. Car was clean and ready to go! Will definitely rent from them again on our next trip to St Maarten.
Rated no. 5
Thrifty
8.3 Excellent (11 reviews)
1 location in Simpson Bay
Thrifty
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 8.3
  • 8.1
  • 8.3
  • 8.5
  • 8.3
Recent reviews
10.0 Excellent15 Aug 2021
Very quick pick up and drop off. Convenient shuttle van.
7.9 Good11 Jul 2021
Our reservation was for two 15 passenger vans. Turns out the location in St Martin does not carry 15 passenger vans. So they gave us two 12 passenger vans and a complementary SUV.
2.0 Mediocre10 May 2021
There was no rental. They never sent me a confirmation email or any documentation I even paid for my rental.
10.0 Excellent7 Oct 2019
Great service
10.0 Excellent22 Mar 2019
Vic was excellent
6.0 Good17 Feb 2019
I didn’t get the car I booked. I got a smaller car.Actually have the cars that people book.
10.0 Excellent14 Mar 2017
Good serviceDrop off right at cruise ship was super convenient.
8.4 Excellent12 Mar 2017
Our #1 Choice for St MaartenShuttle just outside of SXM Airport takes you to the close-by but drivable distance to pick up your car. Always reserve your car prior to your trip for best price online at Thrifty.com, finding an online discount code for example 10% off. For insurance, if you have an American Express, sign up through AmX prior to your trip for a one-time charge of $24.95 on your American Express upon car rental charge; It covers everything except Liability, for the duration of your rental time (ours was 2 weeks) and safely decline Thrifty's daily insurance charges. (If you think your credit card covers you automatically, you may be very surprised just how little those free included coverage actually covers!) Bring a Contract copy with you. Thrifty is pleasant and they have decent prices. You can find slightly cheaper deals elsewhere, but beware of the extra charges others will likely add on.It is customary in St Maarten to sign a blank credit card receipt, just in case the car is damaged or stolen, etc. But they all do this. After numerous years of rentals through Thrifty, we've never had any add-ons we did not expect.
9.6 Excellent28 Nov 2016
Drop off at ferry for no charge!
Show more reviews
Rated no. 6
Dollar
7.8 Good (10 reviews)
1 location in Simpson Bay
Dollar
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 7.8
  • 7.8
  • 7.8
  • 7.6
  • 8
Recent reviews
4.0 Okay28 Dec 2019
Tried to charge me a higher rate than the one that was booked. Check-in personnel were slow and unfriendly. Clearly they did not want to be there.
2.0 Mediocre18 Aug 2017
Dollard don't want to make the deal i reserved on your site. They said you book not at the good price. They charge me 140 usd more Thant i booked with you Very bad experience
8.0 Excellent10 Dec 2016
Friendly people. You can pay by debit card.Still don't know why I had to pay more than rental and insurance ( no damage) Called for info about paying by debit card but got inaccurate info.
7.6 Good21 Oct 2016
Drop off was very pleasant helped by a courteous young ladyP/U was just the opposite agents helped when they got ready no concern for my ttime
Show more reviews
Rated no. 7
Alamo
7.7 Good (16 reviews)
2 locations in Simpson Bay
Alamo
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 7.2
  • 7.7
  • 7.6
  • 7.7
  • 8.2
Recent reviews
6.0 Good14 May 2017
Just okWhile they didn't have my car ready, they gave me another one. The car was cheap relative to others. Overall it was ok and what I expected in the Caribbean.Car wasn't ready for me. Car was not really clean. The van to and from the airport was not very clean and they jammed us into the vehicle.
8.0 Excellent16 Apr 2017
Exactly as agreedI have been going to Sint Maarten for years renting cars. This year Alamo provided the car exactly as per my priceline agreement. No hard sell on insurance and they gave me a car tat had fewer than normal miles.
10.0 Excellent16 Apr 2017
Great Customer ServiceThorough overview of the vehicle and any existing scratches before leaving the site
4.8 Okay11 Apr 2017
Older cars, not maintainedThe price seemed good.First car had serious problems: brakes grinding, brake light on, check engine light on. Returned the car to get another... second car needed tune-up or something, because it kept mis-firing and jerking.
10.0 Excellent26 Mar 2017
It worked like a charm. Everything was on time. Good pickup service. And good people. Would use Alamo next year when I return.
3.6 Mediocre20 Mar 2017
Very disappointingNothingVery expensive to drive a heap -- multiple scrapes and dings, windshield wipers were smeary, tire pressure light came on within first day, check engine light came on on third day, AC was weak (and if turned up made a continuous clicking sound that wouldn't quit until it was turned back down. Drive like a bucket of bolts, and cost nearly $700 for a week (with insurance, which seemed important given the condition of the car, not wanting anything blamed on me). They also take a $750 deposit against your credit card, which they return to you if they deem there is no further damage. We took pictures of the car before leaving the lot, and got that money back.
10.0 Excellent23 Jan 2017
Overall excellent service! Thank you; will rent again next year. Bill
4.0 Okay18 Jan 2017
NothingEvrething.
3.2 Mediocre6 Nov 2016
Try somewhere else if you want a place with servicGot a free upgrade...because they did not have our car in.They asked the hotel so they could reach me to replace the car, then decided I should just stop back in.....stop my vacation to see if they have the car.....not to be a brat, but customer service is their job. I called to check, and they did not pick up or have an answering machine.....don't expect much help. When I returned the car, they said I owed an extra day, and I should check my paper work. I said no, and made them look at the electronic reservation. They copied the item down wrong...keep the reservation information handy as they might try to get an extra day out of you.
10.0 Excellent30 Oct 2016
Very good value. Car functioned very well.Car (Jeep minivan) was bigger than I wished I'd rented for a small Carribbean island. Discovered the check engine light was on and in concern took it back to the rental office where I was assured not to worry....they had checked out the vehicle thoroughly before rental.
Show more reviews
Rated no. 8
Economy Rent a Car
6 Good (2 reviews)
2 locations in Simpson Bay
Economy Rent a Car
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 5
  • 6
  • 5
  • 7
  • 7
Recent reviews
5.2 Okay17 Jan 2017
I had ordered a "standard" car, since we were 2 couples with a considerable amt. of luggage & we recieved an intermediate Kia, in which the driver's side door handle literally broke off the door the second time we opened that door, & we were charged for it "because we broke it" by normally opening the door !! They did exchange the car for a similar one the next day.
6.8 Good17 Sep 2016
Get's the job doneFriendly and efficient service. Great price and nothing of the previous reviews.Car was an older model, a little rough around the edges. You get what you pay for in terms of the vehicle.
Rated no. 9
MEXRENTACAR
5.4 Okay (4 reviews)
1 location in Simpson Bay
MEXRENTACAR
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 6.9
  • 5.9
  • 5.4
  • 7.4
  • 7.9
Recent reviews
10.0 Excellent30 Aug 2021
Incredible service and great value! Having this vehicle made my trip a success and I can’t thank the staff enough for all of their help!
5.9 Okay8 Aug 2021
Service could have been better at the office. Unpleasant staff
1.9 Horrible26 Jul 2021
We were giving a smaller car than what we paid for. The employee said they didn't have any other cars to give us. The car had been wrecked several times. The car didn't have much power so it didn't perform well on the hilly roads. Very disappointed.
4.0 Okay27 Jun 2021
The shuttle guys are very nice and friendly. The employees behind the desk are not very friendly. Anger issues (I guess) but they're not very friendly and honestly they're quite rude.We got a flat tire and the spare was flat also. When had to get our hotel people to help us out because the road side assistance said it would be an hour or more before we received help. Too hot and humid to sit there for an hour. After getting air put into the tour, we took the car to them to let them know the spare is flat and we won't up to a flat tire. They looked at us and questioned us as if it was our fault or as is we were lying about both tires being flat. As if we flew all the way to St. Maarten just to flatten two tires. What would we get out of doing that? Our last day to return the car the guy argued with us saying we owed them $270 BUT we had already paid for the car a few weeks prior. So the man says with an angry attitude, "look Mr. "So & So" you owe us $270 & it will be charged to your card on file. We said our name isn't "......". Turns out he pulled the wrong person's papers. He finds our paper and shows that we have no balance. He says "oh you're good to go". I said that's it? He says yes. I said no sorry, no nothing. He has a slight embarrassed look and says sorry & starts ruffling through the papers as if he was too busy to give us a proper apology. Upon our arrival this same employee was giving another couple with a broken car alarm the same stinky attitude. Honestly all of the employees attitudes are horrible. The price for the car for the week was GREAT! Customer service with Mexcar needs IMPROVEMENT.
Rated no. 10
NU Car
3.9 Mediocre (5 reviews)
1 location in Simpson Bay
NU Car
Locations in Simpson Bay
  • 5.1
  • 3.5
  • 3.9
  • 3.5
  • 3.9
Recent reviews
1.9 Horrible23 Jun 2021
Don’t be fooled by the cheap pricing!! This Nu car rental is not at the Airport, so you will not see signs for them. Another nice guy from a major agency called them for me to pick us up. Then they pick you up in your car, drive you around the airport to a 3rd party agency acting as Nu. It’s a rinky dink place, and not written anywhere, it’s a mandatory purchase of LDW for $6/day!! Also they gave a small economy car as a full size car! In hindsight, reserve from a major car rental.
8.0 Excellent5 May 2021
Easy to book and price was under $50 for the day in smallest car offered.The pick up was a bit to do, when I arrived no one was at the office and I couldn’t reach anyone by phone but the neighboring car rental attendant called them and they arrived quickly. In their defense, I had only booked the car a little over an hour before I arrived. The car was moderately clean and easy check out and back in. I would rent from them again if I need.
Sunnycars
7 locations in Simpson Bay
Sunnycars
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
CarWiz
2 locations in Simpson Bay
CarWiz
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
CCB
2 locations in Simpson Bay
CCB
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Enterprise
2 locations in Simpson Bay
Enterprise
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
National
2 locations in Simpson Bay
National
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Prestige Value Car Rental
2 locations in Simpson Bay
Prestige Value Car Rental
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Right Cars
2 locations in Simpson Bay
Right Cars
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
ADDCAR RENTAL
1 location in Simpson Bay
ADDCAR RENTAL
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Amazon Car Rental
1 location in Simpson Bay
Amazon Car Rental
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Auto Discount Location
1 location in Simpson Bay
Auto Discount Location
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Autounion Car Rental
1 location in Simpson Bay
Autounion Car Rental
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
E-Z Rent-A-Car
1 location in Simpson Bay
E-Z Rent-A-Car
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Emotions Car Rental
1 location in Simpson Bay
Emotions Car Rental
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Empress Rent a Car
1 location in Simpson Bay
Empress Rent a Car
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Europcar
1 location in Simpson Bay
Europcar
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
FLIZZR
1 location in Simpson Bay
FLIZZR
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Golfe Car Rental
1 location in Simpson Bay
Golfe Car Rental
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
GREEN MOTION
1 location in Simpson Bay
GREEN MOTION
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
keddy by Europcar
1 location in Simpson Bay
keddy by Europcar
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Leisure Car Rental
1 location in Simpson Bay
Leisure Car Rental
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Next Level
1 location in Simpson Bay
Next Level
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Ocean Car Rental
1 location in Simpson Bay
Ocean Car Rental
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Priceless
1 location in Simpson Bay
Priceless
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
QUICKLY
1 location in Simpson Bay
QUICKLY
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Rent-A-Wreck
1 location in Simpson Bay
Rent-A-Wreck
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
SURPRICE CAR RENTAL
1 location in Simpson Bay
SURPRICE CAR RENTAL
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
U-Save
1 location in Simpson Bay
U-Save
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Value Car Rental
1 location in Simpson Bay
Value Car Rental
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Zezgo
1 location in Simpson Bay
Zezgo
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
Zoom Rent A Car
1 location in Simpson Bay
Zoom Rent A Car
Locations in Simpson Bay
Recent reviews
120 travellers who rented a car in Simpson Bay gave the car agency they used an average rating of 7.3

Car rental locations in or near Simpson Bay

Good to know

Most popular car type

Mini

When to book a rental car in Simpson Bay

Average daily price per month
Rental car prices as pick-up date approaches

Top tips for hiring a car in Simpson Bay

  • Book your rental car in Simpson Bay at least 6 weeks before your trip in order to get a below-average price
  • Mini rental cars in Simpson Bay are around 41% cheaper than other car types, on average

FAQs about hiring a car in Simpson Bay

  • Based on ratings and reviews from real users on KAYAK, the best car hire company in Simpson Bay is Ace (7.1, 98 reviews).

  • Mini (Fiat 500 or similar) is the most frequently booked car hire type in Simpson Bay.

  • Take a look at our extensive car hire location map to find the best car hire deals near you.

  • A Mini car rental in Simpson Bay costs $34 per day, on average.

  • A Economy car rental in Simpson Bay costs $36 per day, on average.

  • A Compact car rental in Simpson Bay costs $39 per day, on average.