Mackinaw City motels

Pros: The rooms were quite clean.

Cons: I get that lodging in Mackinaw City is hard to come by on summer weekends, but this was way too expensive for what we got. The hotel wi-fi was nonfunctional, presumably because our room was too far from the single router in the office. If I ever stay in Mackinaw City again, I'll be sure to make reservations farther ahead of time.

Pros: This vintage motel was big & roomy. I'm not sure if it has always been this well-maintained, or if it was restored during a renovation... It looks "old" but it feels / smells / seems new. It was like being in a time warp, except the beds and water pressure were better, there was a fridge, and we couldn't hear the neighbors! The owners were on-site, helpful, and friendly. My husband and I are 60s and 70s kids, so we thought it was fabulous!

Cons: Honestly, there is nothing I did not like about this place. We're DEFINITELY staying here again on our next trip north; I'm not even shopping around!

Pros: Very nice shoreline, with chairs to relax and firepits

Cons: Heard footsteps of upstairs guests

Pros: Very clean, great location. Pool and hot tub area was maintained well. Breakfast was pretty average, but the host was friendly and kept everything in stock. Fire pits on the beach were a great touch and the view is fantastic.

Cons: Room was small- it had everything we needed, it just felt a little cramped.

Pros: Neat and tidy. Very clean. Friendly staff with all the answers. Great place to stay!

Cons: Nothing

Pros: I liked the atmosphere of being in the city. I enjoyed the continental breakfast.

Cons: Door on the room we stayed in was a little tough to open and close.

Cons: The beds were very uncomfortable, and the shower was moldy.

Cons: Breakfast could of been a little better. More variety to choose from.

Pros: Wasn't much for breakfast, rate a 4 out of 10

Cons: Thought the price was high for what you got.

Pros: Cleanliness and location

Pros: Comfortable bed, clean room. Location and parking was very convenient.

Cons: Cheap paper products and towels. Breakfast was not enjoyable - watered down coffee, stale cold cereal and “hot items” were cold, processed meat and eggs. No rugs at door entrances and made for wet, slippery floors in breakfast room.

Pros: I like the location best. As soon as we pulled into town, it was there!! You could see the whole length of the street, right up to the ferry, where we'd travel to the Island!!! The beds were so clean and comfy! Best sleep I'd had in a long time!!

Pros: Location is perfect and everything was clean.

Cons: Nothing, it was great!

Pros: It was going to be late before we got there so we called to let them know that and we were going to only stay 1 night instead of 2. They said I'd have to pay for both nights but if I cancel I'd only have to pay for 1 night. I said paying for 1 night would be better then paying for no night and I told him that the second day we were going to the locks but the weather was going to be in the low 40's and we changed our minds. He said that was too bad but would still have to pay. He didn't want to work with us at all so we stayed else where in mackinaw for 1 night and enjoyed our day.

Cons: Zero personality

Pros: Staff was friendly and helpful.

Cons: WiFi wouldn't work for us even with password. Could be because we had Sprint. Pool was super small.

Pros: Cleaning staff was nice and personable.

Cons: Breakfast was too short (1.5 hours) and was being cleaned up 5-10 min before the end of the time so it made your selection to be between 2-3 cold items.

Pros: Convenient to downtown

Cons: NOT ENOUGH PARKING SPACES. Breakfast was a little sparse.

Pros: Informative front desk. Room was clean & quiet.

Cons: No

Pros: Staff

Cons: I booked my room at Mackinaw Budget Inn, but since the hotel got full even though I had confirmed reservation, I was put in an another hotel which was pretty bad and dingy

Pros: bed was hard Had to walk over to neighboring motel for breakfast

Pros: Hotel was as expected. Staff were friendly, and the room was clean.

Cons: The biggest disappointment was breakfast. All that was available were a few mini donuts, coffee and juice.

Cons: Toilet was not working we had to get a plunger to stay in operating. Had to walk quite a way to get coffee and the “free” breakfast consisted of tiny donuts and blueberry muffins. Beds were very hard and sheets felt starched

Pros: It was close enough to everything that you could walk everywhere .

Pros: good lighting in the room. nice to have a fridge and microwave!

Cons: signage was bad/hard to find. bed was uncomfortable, bathtub dripped and was stained. $220 for this room???? REALLY??

Pros: How helpful and friendly staff was and how clean rooms were.

Cons: Need to put no slip strips in bath tub and a possible bar to hold on when getting out. Plastic shower curtain behind regular shower curtain to help with water dripping.

Pros: breakfast was not as good as we had hoped

Cons: not much selection and not very good

Pros: location for what i was there for

Cons: not undertnding the help no vending machines any were near chech in was at another hotel next dooor not worth the money

Pros: Very friendly staff all around

Cons: Carpet was very dirty probably needs a good cleaning but everything else was fine.

Pros: I loved the price, the staff was very friendly, the location is only a few minutes away from all the action, the room was very clean.

Cons: It was outdated- you get what you pay for as far as amenities. Walls are pretty thin.

Pros: cute room

Cons: bathroom door and walls were dirty

Pros: The room we stayed in was super clean and when we switched to a handicap room it was done without a problem. We don't consider ourselves to be handicap but the toilets are set so low it makes it impossible for "old" knees to operate.

Cons: Our only problem as stated above was with the bathrooms. Even the handicap had a low toilet but it at least had hand rails to help. We really like your hotel and try to stay there every year when on color tour. But the older we get the harder it gets.

Cons: When we arrived upon check in we were informed the room we booked online was not and they wanted to give us a different for the same amount, which if we would if boomed the standard room it would have been less. As we are discussing this with the employee (Andre Brown) he called his manager(Rick Brown) and as they were discuss Andre was laughing being very disrespectful toward us. When they refused to give us the room at the lesser rate we discussed canceling altogether. While still in the process of discussing with Andre, Andre claims our reservation had been canceled. As we continued to discuss miss this matter he now calls a female to discuss and she tells us they don’t have any vacancies what so ever. I ask her what about the room that we were they to check in for? She finally agreed that room is vacant bit is not the standard rate. The final outcome basically was that we could not get the room we reserved at a higher price (standard room price was available when we made reservation) for standard fee so they agreed there would be no cancelation fee but could not get that on paperwork. Rick the manager wouldn’t even get on phone with me to discuss. He made Andre do it all even after I requested to speak with the manager directly. I feel we were treated disrespectful and that didn’t even want to negotiate with us. It was there way or no way. I am not sure I would ever consider booking at this location again.

Pros: Location is grate .

Cons: When I check in . Front stuff is looks like very tired Or sickness? Anyway he is not nice and very rude. Never go back again this hotel.

Pros: The location, that it included breakfast, the price. Not fancy, but nice, clean and comfortable.

Pros: Big roons

Cons: Little cleaner.

Pros: Great location. Out the front door you can see the bridge and The lake. At night the bridge is all lit up and has great views from the park across the street.

Cons: The room had a musty smell. My guess would be the jacuzzi tub. Also after using the jacuzzi there was floaties that must be scale from the hard water and not good cleaning.

Pros: Location was great, room very pretty and clean. Loved the furniture. Staff very nice.

Cons: Breakfast food was quite sparse...

Pros: Location was within 4 blocks of main shopping

Cons: The room was dirty and beds were not impressive. I will not stay at this one ever again. It also let a guest take a dog into the pool area.

Pros: Very nice hotel

Cons: Need more comfortable beds

Cons: breakfast area is tiny and not nearly big enough for everyone trying to eat in the morning.

Cons: The pool was closed, didnt have that shown like other hotels, there were only 3 guests so they didnt even open the free breakfast.

Pros: Great staff and my room was very clean

Cons: Breakfast area was cramped

Pros: I enjoyed the location. Overall, the staff were friendly and helpful.

Pros: Location

Cons: Wi-fi was very poor, pool & hottub were closed, had to go to hotel next door for breakfast.

Pros: Great location, friendly staff.

Cons: Room could have been cleaner!

Pros: Good location

Cons: It was freezing cold in our room

Pros: Beach access.

Cons: Main parking lot did not have enough spaces for all guests. Overflow parking lot on the other side of the building was dirty and both parking lots flooded after a overnight thunderstorm.

Pros: The hotel was centrally located which was great. The staff was very friendly as well. The view was great. The breakfast was good.

Cons: The hotel room was not the cleanest.

Pros: Nice location, walking distance to some restaurants and attractions

Cons: Waited for desk to find a clean room at checkin, but were given a dirty room. Dingy and dated with peeling flooring in the bathroom and no privacy curtains on the window just blackout. No towels at the pool. No apology was given for any of the issues.

Pros: Nothing! The walls, hard surfaces, carpets all needed a good and thorough cleaning. The HVAC unit was in need of repair.

Cons: The filth in the room and broken down look of the motel over all.

Pros: Hamilton was great to stay at

Cons: We didn't stay at Super 8 they were closed for the season went to Hamilton's was not told that's where the reservations were