La Collegiata

great quiet location with amazing sunset view over old town. decent, comfy room with huge shower-bathroom. Beautiful pool area. Nice morning walk thru surrounding wineries and villas. Excellent breakfast.

Lack of personal attention from the stuff and manager.

Amazing charming place, nicely decorated, looked after and very quiet. Great swim pool area with the bar, big room with massive bathroom. Very friendly staff - gave us great recommendations for dinner. Great location with lovely views.

The room was smelling a bit dump; breakfast was good but scrambled eggs were watery.

Perfect “simple luxury” accommodation with a scenic view over San Gimignano, wonderful relaxed atmosphere, cosy beautiful garden with a pool, historic interiors, nice and friendly personnel and delicious in-house restaurant. Beginning of June is a great time to travel as it was not too busy and not too hot. Definitely a place I would recommend to everyone traveling to San Gimignano

Tiny flaws: We stayed in the second most expensive room of the hotel and the only one with an open terrace overlooking San Gimignano. But the terrace was absolutely empty and uncomfortable. Only a cheap and ugly garden table and a couple of equally cheap and ugly chairs. Not a single pot of flowers or anything. Quite a contrast to the hotel interiors and the room itself when you step onto the terrace. Zero longing to spend any time on it. Why not making it nice and cosy and beautiful and let your guests enjoy the evenings and sunsets in the privacy of their room? Bottled water in the room every day and not only on check-in is a must for hotels of this level, especially where it‘s hot, and where there’s wine and one might have too much of it and be in the need for a glass of water in the middle of the night. Additional charge for egg dishes (EUR 7) and tiny freshly squeezed juices (EUR 7) at breakfast is quite mauvais ton. In my experience breakfast is one of the key things that let one feel the class of a hotel. Saving money on the breakfast is a mistake.

Also good restaurant on property